The optimistic, pregnant squad captain turned criminal mastermind. James Marsden The supportive, dim-witted star football quarterback. Kansas Hill Mena Suvari The rebellious squad member with a mother in prison. Cleo Miller Melissa George The obsessive Conan the Barbarian fan. Hannah Wald Rachel Blanchard The deeply religious and sweet cheerleader. Lucy Whitman Sara Marsh The brilliant, hyper-studious geek of the group. Fern Rogers Alexandra Holden